Clergy Abuse Tracker
More Pre-11/2002 Archives

Saturday, July 27, 2002

WASHINGTON (DC)
Psychiatrist on Catholic Panel Criticized
Washington Post
By Caryle Murphy and Sandra G. Boodman
Washington Post Staff Writers
The only psychiatrist appointed this week to serve on the Roman Catholic Church's national sexual abuse review board is closely affiliated with a controversial group devoted to combating what it believes are false memories of childhood abuse that never occurred.
Paul R. McHugh, former chairman of the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, serves on the scientific advisory board of the False Memory Syndrome Foundation, a Philadelphia-based group many therapists view as unsympathetic to victims of child sexual abuse. McHugh has testified on behalf of people accused of child abuse.
"People are upset by this because he's clearly someone who wants to downplay the horror of sexual abuse," said Paul Fink, professor of psychiatry at Temple University and past president of the American Psychiatric Association, who described false memory syndrome as "junk science."
Fink said he did not believe McHugh's views were representative of clinicians, most of whom accept the notion that traumatic memories are sometimes repressed as a way for victims to cope.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 09:34:04 AM MINNEAPOLIS-ST.PAUL (MN)
Catholic dioceses find insurance falls short in sex abuse cases
Star Tribune
Bob von Sternberg
As accusations of sexual abuse by priests continue to pile up, the expensive experience of two Minnesota dioceses could provide a cautionary tale for the nation's bishops.
Bottom line: It will take a lot more than liability insurance to cover the cost of settlements and civil judgments being paid to abuse victims.
"Dioceses are going to run out of coverage pretty quick," said P.J. Crowley, spokesman for the Insurance Information Institute, a New York-based trade association. "None can assume their insurance will cover all their costs in these cases."
The old case involving the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis and the Diocese of Winona is a telling example of this trend, in which church officials are forced to scrounge for other pots of money to pay settlements that have been counted in the millions of dollars.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 08:05:06 AM

LOUISVILLE (KY)
Opening of Lexington abuse case sought
The Courier-Journal
By Deborah Yetter
dyetter@courier-journal.com
The Courier-Journal has asked the state Court of Appeals to immediately open all records of a sealed case in which five people sued the Roman Catholic church in Lexington, alleging they were sexually abused as children by priests.
In a motion filed yesterday in Frankfort, the newspaper also asked the court to open all future hearings to the media and public. The motion also seeks permission for the newspaper to intervene in the case and have access to all sealed files.
''We're doing this because it raises very serious questions about secret proceedings in court,'' said Jon Fleischaker, a lawyer for The CourierJournal. ''The public has a right to know what's going on.''
John Famularo, a lawyer for the Lexington diocese -- which seeks to keep the case sealed -- could not be reached for comment.
The newspaper's action comes after lawyers for the Lexington diocese persuaded appeals court Judge Julia Tackett to keep the case sealed while the court reviews an order from a Fayette Circuit judge to open it to the public. The appeals court is scheduled to hear the matter on Aug. 5.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 07:54:52 AM

LOUISVILLE (KY)
Archdiocese seeks suits' dismissal
Church cites age of alleged abuse, denies cover-up
The Courier-Journal
By Peter Smith
psmith@courier-journal.com
The Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Louisville is asking Jefferson Circuit Court to dismiss the 156 lawsuits filed since April by people alleging they were molested by its priests and employees.
In filings with the court yesterday, the church contends the cases should be barred by the statute of limitations, because the alleged incidents occurred too long ago, and denies officials covered up any abuse.
The filings also say any wrongdoing that may have occurred is at least partly ''the fault of person(s) other than'' archdiocesean officials or the alleged victim.
The archdiocese also makes extensive inquiries into the plaintiffs' personal histories, asking them to produce diaries as well as medical and psychiatric records related to any alleged abuse they may have suffered at the hands of church employees or anyone else during their lifetimes.
The church also is asking for the plaintiffs' educational backgrounds and for information on any problems they may have ever had with drugs or alcohol.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 07:52:27 AM

CHICAGO (Ill.)
Man hospitalized in threats to pope
Chicago Tribune
CHICAGO -- A 42-year-old West Side man who recently worked for Chicago Catholic Charities was arrested Friday and hospitalized after making death threats to Cardinal Francis George and Pope John Paul II.
The man went to the Roman Catholic cardinal's mansion in the 1500 block of North State Parkway on Wednesday morning and asked for an audience, nuns told police.
Upon learning that the cardinal was in Toronto with the pontiff for a youth rally, the man began criticizing how the Catholic leaders had handled allegations of sexual abuse by Catholic priests, police said.
"He said he was going to kill Cardinal George and the pope . . . that they weren't doing enough about pedophiles," a police spokesman said.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 07:47:24 AM
CHICAGO (Ill.)
Man who threatened cardinal put in hospital
Chicago Sun-Times
BY FRANK MAIN CRIME REPORTER
A man suspected of threatening to kill Cardinal Francis George was taken Friday to Ravenswood Hospital for psychiatric evaluation, and police said they don't expect the man will face any criminal charges.
Police said the 42-year-old Chicago man went to the cardinal's residence in the 1500 block of North State on Wednesday and told a nun who answered the door he wanted to speak with the cardinal. He was told the cardinal was out of town--he's in Toronto with the pope for World Youth Day festivities.
The man then said he didn't think George was doing enough to address allegations of priests engaging in sexual abuse, that he was God and that the "angel of death" was going to visit the cardinal, the nun told police.
After a videotape recorded by a security camera at the cardinal's residence was played on TV newscasts, two people called police and said the man on the tape looked like a Catholic Charities employee who quit July 19.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 07:41:36 AM
ALBANY (NY)
Albany diocese says Fitzpatrick admitted abuse
Daily Gazette
By JILL BRYCE
Gazette Reporter
ALBANY - A priest who attended seminary with Bishop Howard J. Hubbard was removed from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany in the mid-1990s after he admitted he sexually abused a minor.
The diocese confirmed on Friday that the Rev. John Fitzpatrick, who was assigned to St. Mary's Church in Crescent at the time, was removed after he admitted to the sexual misconduct, according to the Rev. Kenneth Doyle, chancellor of the diocese.
Doyle also said Friday that the diocese has received several new allegations of sexual abuse by priests in recent weeks and these claims are being investigated. No additional priests have been removed from public ministry or admitted sexually abusing minors, he said.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/27/2002 07:39:18 AM

LARGO (FL)
Priest's list of accusers now up to 18 names
More and more men are stepping forward with allegations each time the case receives new publicity, says attorney Joseph Saunders.

St. Petersburg Times
By STEPHEN NOHLGREN, Times Staff Writer
LARGO -- A month after the Rev. Robert Schaeufele's arrest on molestation charges, several more men have come forward to claim they were sexually abused by Schaeufele during his nearly three decades with the Catholic Diocese of St. Petersburg.
At least 18 men now say Schaeufele abused them when they were teenagers or boys, St. Petersburg attorney Joseph Saunders said Friday. Their ages during the alleged assaults ranged from 8 to 15. They belonged to five different churches in three counties, where the man affectionately known as "Father Bob" served as pastor or associate pastor.
"I've also had a number of calls from parents who believe their children were abused," Saunders said, "but their children haven't admitted it yet."
Since April, Saunders said, 14 victims have hired him to represent them in civil dealings with the church. Another four have contacted him, described sexual abuse by Schaeufele, but chosen not to hire him.





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 07:33:54 AM

DOVER (N.H.)
Former Dover priest, accused of abuse, writes book on faith healing
Foster's Democrat
By BRAD MORIN
Democrat Staff Writer
DOVER — Retired priest Joseph T. Maguire, accused in two lawsuits of molesting altar boys, has written a book on faith healing and is featured on the Web site of an online ministry.
The Catholic Diocese of Manchester revoked Maguire’s permission for ministry after he allegedly confessed to sexually abusing boys in Hudson and Dover. But an online biography of Maguire describes him as a "dynamic preacher-healer" with a special ministry to the terminally ill.
After the Diocese of Manchester learned of the Internet posting, Maguire was contacted by the Rev. Edward Arsenault, who is in charge of the bishop’s sexual abuse policies. Diocesan spokesman Pat McGee said Arsenault reiterated to Maguire that he is no longer permitted to function as a priest.
"He said he ought to cease or desist doing so, even on the Web," McGee said Thursday.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 06:57:01 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Settlement arguments offered
Boston Globe
By Kathleen Burge, Globe Staff
Lawyers for 86 victims allegedly abused by priest knew that the settlement agreement they had negotiated with the Archdiocese of Boston was risky because the church had not yet come up with the money, archdiocese lawyers are arguing on the eve of a mini-trial to determine whether the agreement still stands.
In court papers filed yesterday in Suffolk Superior Court, they describe the negotiated agreement as the first step toward a final settlement, which would become official once the money was secured and everyone had signed it.
But lawyers for the alleged victims of former priest and convicted molester John J. Geoghan are accusing the archdiocese of fraud, saying the archdiocese publicly embraced the agreement and then abandoned it.
Offering a glimpse into the proceeding that begins Wednesday, lawyers on both sides yesterday submitted witness lists and summaries of their arguments to Superior Court Judge Constance M. Sweeney. She will decide whether the $15 million to $30 million agreement is a binding contract.
Sweeney has hinted that she thought a settlement had been reached. And she has said the archdiocese cannot get out of the settlement agreement by invoking the vote not to fund it by Cardinal Bernard F. Law's handpicked finance council.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 06:47:43 AM
BOSTON (Mass.)
Law affirms church doctrine to youths
Cardinal touches on suicide, female ordination, gays

Boston Globe
By Michael Paulson, Globe Staff,
TORONTO - Cardinal Bernard F. Law, dancing and singing with an exuberant crowd of young Boston Catholics, yesterday declared that those who believe the church's teachings on divorce, women's ordination, and other hot-button topics will change when the pope dies are mistaken.
Law, making his first public appearance during World Youth Day, told a group of about 550 young adults from Boston that the church's teachings come from God, not popes, and are therefore immutable. In response to questions from the local pilgrims, he offered staunch and empathic defenses of the church's opposition to suicide, homosexual sex, and the ordination of women...
Interviewed afterward, the young adults gave a variety of explanations for their applause, with some offering unmitigated support for their archbishop, and others saying that they are critical of Law's handling of sexually abusive priests, but still wanted to show their support for him as their bishop or their gratitude to him for accompanying them to Toronto.
''As Catholics we have been taught to forgive, so even though he has messed up, he's a good cardinal,'' said Francisco ''Quico'' Sierra, 18, of Dedham.
Mariangela Sullivan, 18, of Wellesley, said, ''because of his status as cardinal, and because he's leading the Mass, he got the applause. It's not because we support him - many of us don't.''





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/27/2002 06:43:58 AM

Friday, July 26, 2002


SALEM (Mass.)
Don't refuse gift from the faithful
The Salem Evening News
Editorial: It is difficult to understand Cardinal Bernard Law's refusal to accept donations raised by Voice of the Faithful.
The many social programs funded by the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston depend on money from church members for their existence.
But donations, among them the Cardinal's Appeal, are way down this year.
Church officials won't say by how much but one estimate puts the figure at 30 to 40 percent.
Law has announced that the archdiocese would reduce its budget by one-third and cut 15 positions as well as aid to parishes, schools and hospitals.
The archdiocese blames the poor economy and the sexual abuse scandal for the decline. No doubt both are factors.
Beyond the drop in donations, another result of the sex scandal was the formation of Voice of the Faithful, an organization of laity determined to reform the church. Formed just five months ago, the group has grown to 19,000 members nationwide. Voice of the Faithful held its first national convention in Boston last week.
The group wants to provide a way for Catholics upset by the scandal to continue donating to vital charities without going through the archdiocese. Its "Voice of Compassion" fund would bypass church hierarchy and provide money directly to archdiocese charities.
But the archdiocese will not accept the money.
Cardinal Law has spoken much of healing and coming together in the church since the sex scandal was first exposed. But Law's actions differ greatly from his words.
Law has fought Voice of the Faithful since its inception. He discouraged clergy from assisting dissident groups in any manner. Now comes the refusal to accept its offer of financial help.
Voice of the Faithful is seeking to help the very charities that make the Catholic Church so vital to the community. The church should welcome the effort.
Law's obstinacy smacks of hubris and is keeping the church divided, not bringing it together.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:21:25 PM
ALBANY (NY)
Disgraced priest's self-serving views don't deserve attention
Times-Union
Letter to the Editor: I found Andrew Tilghman's interview with child-abuser Father John Bertolucci to be very disturbing (July 21). I wish the word "disgraced" instead of the frequently cited weaker term "embarrassed" had been used throughout the article.
I was sickened by the media personality and nationally prominent televangelist Bertolucci's constantly self-serving comments. How reassuring that he is a "beloved author" and states that he is "deeply loved by a lot of people," received "supportive voice mails" and that "no one has criticized him to his face."
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/26/2002 03:36:15 PM
WEST PALM BEACH (Fl)
West Palm Beach attorney Ron Zeller talks to The Florida Catholic about the Ecumenical Review Panel and the church scandals.
'Open and Faithful'

Florida Catholic
By Tom Tracy
From his office in the Esparente building in West Palm Beach, business attorney Ron Zeller recalls how he once held the record for working on the most voluminous legal case in Dade County...
Zeller's varied business experience, civic record and legal background -- along with a penchant for precision in communications -- were tapped by the Diocese of Palm Beach earlier this year in appointing him head of the communications subcommittee of the Ecumenical Review Panel.
Established by Palm Beach diocesan Apostolic Administrator Father James Murtagh, the panel -- comprising 17 members of the community -- produced "Open and Faithful," a comprehensive study of short and long-term needs of the diocese in the wake of the clergy sex abuse scandal.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/26/2002 03:30:47 PM

MILWAUKEE (Wisc.)
Ex-minister guilty of exposure
Former youth leader in Bay also faces charges in explicit e-mails

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
By MARIE ROHDE and LISA SINK
of the Journal Sentinel staff
A former youth minister for the United Methodist Church of Whitefish Bay pleaded no contest Thursday to a charge that he exposed himself to a 17-year-old boy who spent the night with him at his congregation-owned home last August.
The youth minister, Kurt Danskin, 35, also was charged earlier this week in Waukesha County with disorderly conduct, a misdemeanor, in connection with allegations that he had sent the same boy sexually explicit e-mails sometime before May 2001, according to court records. He is to appear in court Aug. 14 on that charge.
Although the allegations came to light last fall, the youth minister was not fired from the Whitefish Bay church until Feb. 13, when church officials were told that the minister was being investigated by the Waukesha County district attorney's office in connection with he e-mail incident.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 08:08:42 AM

Member of Sex Abuse Panel Upsets Some
The New York Times
By ANTHONY DePALMA and LAURIE GOODSTEIN
With memories, some from long ago, at the heart of many reports that priests committed sexual abuse, the appointment to a national lay board of a prominent psychiatrist who has crusaded against the validity of repressed memories has upset victims' groups and reignited a fierce debate among psychiatric professionals.
The psychiatrist, Dr. Paul R. McHugh, is former chairman of the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine in Baltimore. He has been one of the strongest critics of psychiatric therapy based on the technique that traumatic experiences, especially in young people, can be subconsciously repressed for years.
Dr. McHugh has testified on behalf of accused sexual abusers, including at least one priest, who faced the statements of adults who said they had repressed memories of molestation for years before recovering them. In one case that went as far as the Supreme Court, Dr. McHugh testified that the accusers' memories of abuse were, in fact, false.
There are few issues in psychiatry more controversial than repressed memory. Other psychiatrists who work extensively with victims say Dr. McHugh's strong positions against repressed memory and his longstanding support for the False Memory Syndrome Foundation, an organization in Philadelphia that challenges statements that support repressed memory, will add skepticism to reports of clergy abuse.
"This appointment is an insult to victims and to professionals who have worked to present balanced and scientifically and theoretically sound paradigms of trauma," said Mary Gail Frawley-O'Dea, a psychologist and psychoanalyst in New York who addressed the Roman Catholic bishops who gathered last month in Dallas to lay out a plan for dealing with the sexual-abuse scandals that have shaken the church.
"The fact," Ms. Frawley-O'Dea said, "that he was affiliated with this organization to me disqualifies him for being on this particular panel at this particular time in the history of the church."




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:43:26 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Talks Fail in Claims of Abuse by Priests
The New York Times
By PAM BELLUCK
BOSTON, July 25 — More than a month after settlement talks began between the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Boston and lawyers representing 240 people who claim they were sexually abused by priests, the plaintiffs' lawyers said today that negotiations had broken down and no settlement could be reached.
The four plaintiffs' lawyers, who together represent most of the current abuse claims against the archdiocese, said they would take the cases back to court, and they filed a motion today seeking to depose the archbishop, Cardinal Bernard F. Law, on Aug. 5.
"There are a variety of financial and nonfinancial issues that we just weren't able to get done," said one of the plaintiffs' lawyers, Roderick MacLeish Jr.
"They didn't honestly come close to anything that would resolve any case financially," said one plaintiff, Rodney Ford, whose son Greg, 24, contends he was abused repeatedly over six years by the Rev. Paul R. Shanley at a church in the Boston suburb of Newton, Mass. "I just don't think they're being sincere about the commitment to start selling property, which they need to do to raise the money and to take care of these people. Eventually they're going to have to make the money come from somewhere."




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:39:18 AM
GERMANY
German Church Is Learning From U.S. Mistakes on Abuse
The New York Times
By STEVEN ERLANGER
BERLIN, July 25 — Michael S., now 33, was an altar boy 24 years ago in a Roman Catholic parish in Bavaria when his priest molested him.
Even today, he says with revulsion, "I can feel this perfectly."
Later, he and his mother complained, but the church "hushed up everything," he said. When the priest was accused of similar behavior in another parish, they contacted the vicar general in Würzburg, who was willing to talk, but offered no compensation for therapy or for the abuse itself.
His mother says now that they should have sued the church, to get a response. "We should do it just like in America," she told the news magazine Der Spiegel.
The Roman Catholic Church in Germany is also paying attention to the lessons from the United States, where the church has been convulsed by accusations of pedophilia.
Church leaders here are talking openly about cases of sexual assault by priests against minors, and Cardinal Karl Lehmann, the archbishop of Mainz, warns of more revelations to come. "There are cases emerging of sexual assault by priests on minors, particularly boys," he said in a statement. "The sober view is that we can expect more revelations."



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:35:07 AM

Long-term crisis solutions
The Tidings
By Rev. Richard P. McBrien
Long after the memories of the recent meeting of the U.S. bishops in Dallas have faded, the Catholic Church will be addressing the same kinds of pastoral challenges that it has been confronting since its founding 2,000 years ago.
The church is the community of those who believe Jesus Christ to be the Lord of history and the redeemer of the whole of humankind. As such, it is the community of his disciples, or followers. It strives to incorporate and embody his values and his vision so that the lives of each can become, over time, conformed more perfectly to his.
This means that the church must constantly seek to instill in its members the virtues of love, justice, mercy, forgiveness and self-sacrifice. That is why the church has produced, out of its own limited resources, so many schools, hospitals, orphanages, homeless shelters and organizations to bring aid to the poor, the sick and the troubled.





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:26:08 AM
BOSTON (Mass.)
Catholic Charities shifts on lay group's fund-raising
Boston Globe
By Sacha Pfeiffer and Stephen Kurkjian, Globe Staff
Contrary to earlier statements, a spokeswoman for Catholic Charities said yesterday that the organization will not accept donations from the lay reform group Voice of the Faithful until its 50-member board of trustees has voted on the issue.
''If we were approached by Voice of the Faithful we would seek to work out an agreement with them,'' said Catholic Charities spokeswoman Maureen March. ''We would bring it to the board of trustees.''
Her statement was the latest in a series of conflicting responses from church and charity officials after the Boston archdiocese's announcement Monday that it, Catholic Charities, and Caritas Christi, the Catholic health care network, would reject funds raised by Voice of the Faithful for church agencies, schools, ministries, and hospitals.
But in an interview with the Globe on Tuesday, March said that Catholic Charities, the principal social service agency for the archdiocese, ''will not turn down any donation.'' And a board member with the agency criticized Cardinal Bernard F. Law's decision to reject donations from Voice of the Faithful, which has launched an initiative to raise money from people boycotting the Cardinal's Appeal because of the clergy sexual abuse scandal.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:19:55 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Lawyers, church say talks are at impasse
Boston Globe
By Stephen Kurkjian and Kathleen Burge, Globe Staff
A six-week effort between the Boston Archdiocese and three Boston law firms to settle some 200 claims of clergy sexual abuse ended without success yesterday, lawyers for the victims and the archdiocese said.
The two sides had agreed on June 19 to declare a 30-day truce in pursuing the claims through the courts and added a two-week extension earlier this month. Although the extension does not officially end until next Friday, lawyers for the victims said longstanding obstacles for a resolution of the claims remained and they needed to resume legal preparation for their cases as soon as possible.
The cases will now proceed in court, with the first step being the resumption of the deposition of Cardinal Bernard F. Law on Aug. 5.
The Rev. Christopher Coyne, a spokesman for the archdiocese, said following the statements of the victims' lawyers that the church expected the talks toward reaching a settlement to continue in the coming weeks even as the case proceeds through the courts. ''There is nothing to say that the two processes cannot go on at the same time,'' Coyne said.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 07:16:54 AM

CONCORD (N.H.)
MacCormack once investigated for inappropriate comments
Foster's Democrat
By J.M. HIRSCH
Associated Press Writer
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — A Roman Catholic priest who is suing the Diocese of Manchester once was investigated for making an inappropriate comment to a teenage boy.
According to a police report, authorities in Salem questioned the Rev. James A. MacCormack in September 1998 after the boy told his parents the priest had made a profane remark to him while the two painted a church school a month earlier.
The police concluded that while the comment was inappropriate, MacCormack had done nothing criminal.
MacCormack said Thursday he regretted making the remark as soon as he had spoken, had meant nothing by it and quickly apologized to the boy.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 06:58:26 AM
JAFFREY (N.H.)
Police probed remark
by Rev. MacCormack

The Union Leader
By KATHRYN MARCHOCKI
Union Leader Staff
The Jaffrey priest who this week exposed the lurid lifestyle of a dead Manchester priest himself was investigated by police for an inappropriate sexual remark he made to a teenager four years ago.
The 14-year-old boy’s parents reported the incident to police in August of 1998, saying the Rev. James A. “Seamus” MacCormack made an obscene remark to their son while the priest was associate pastor at St. Joseph Church in Salem, according to police reports.
The teenager and several friends volunteered to help MacCormack paint St. Joseph School. While horsing around, the 14-year-old’s ball cap was smeared with paint. Twice he asked MacCormack if he would pay to replace it, the police report said.
“Father Seamus pointed to his own crotch” and made an obscene remark to the boy, Sgt. Mark Cavanaugh wrote in his report.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 06:39:18 AM

MANCHESTER (N.H.)
Bishop McCormack
'humbled, humiliated'

The Union Leader
By KATHRYN MARCHOCKI
Union Leader Staff
Manchester Bishop John B. McCormack yesterday said he is “humbled” and “humiliated” to realize decisions he made about abusive priests — though well-intentioned at the time — sometimes caused more harm than good.
“As a bishop, I have been humbled by these past six months because I’ve become even much more aware of myself as a person and my limitations . . . and what effect my judgments and my decisions and recommendations have had on the protection of children,” the bishop told the Queen City Manchester Rotary Club.
“As a bishop, I have been humiliated, too, because I really feel that many of the things that I thought we were doing that were good, in retrospect were not as effective, and probably were even counterproductive to the healing of victims and to the good handling of priests,” he added.
As a former top aide to Cardinal Bernard F. Law of Boston charged with handling clergy who sexually abused children, McCormack oversaw the Revs. Paul S. Shanley and Ronald H. Paquin, two of the most notorious alleged offenders to emerge in the scandal that has rocked the Catholic church this year.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 06:36:15 AM

LAWRENCE (Mass.)
Lawrence native to help church's children
The Eagle-Tribune
By Yadira Betances
Eagle-Tribune Writer
A Lawrence native and leading voice in psychiatry has been appointed to a high-profile board to oversee the implementation of the new sex abuse policy in the Roman Catholic Church.
Dr. Paul R. McHugh, who was raised on Tower Hill and is the brother of Lawrence School Committee member Suzanne McHugh Piscitello, will sit alongside Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating and former White House Chief of Staff Leon Panetta, supervising the new Office for Child and Youth Protection, approved by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops last month.
"This is a terrible scandal -- a caldron of confusion," McHugh said of the crisis in the church. "You have to bring light to this. The best thing is to talk about it. The committee will look over whether the bishops are following regulations and give advice on research being done."




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/26/2002 06:27:41 AM
TORONTO
U.S. Catholics say pope's visit is not diminished by sex abuse crisis
Yahoo! News
By RACHEL ZOLL, AP Religion Writer
TORONTO - While 17-year-old Stesha Colby prayed every day for a chance to see Pope John Paul ( news - web sites) II, some of her friends back in Tennessee wondered how she could be such a loyal Roman Catholic.
They asked about her devotion to a church that has sometimes failed to protect children from molesters in the clergy. Her response: There's a difference between the faith and the men who lead it.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/26/2002 05:20:13 AM
TRUCKEE (CA)
3rd search of ex-priest's Truckee home comes up empty
San Jose Mercury News
July 24, 2002
TRUCKEE, Calif. (AP) - Police using radar equipment again searched the vacation home of a former priest charged with child molestation, but for the third time the quest for clues turned up empty.
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/26/2002 05:16:58 AM

Thursday, July 25, 2002


Heed lessons of church scandal
USA Today
Opinion by Kendra Hurley
At a convention Saturday of some 4,000 lay Catholics, victims of priests described, in devastating detail, the nightmare of sexual abuse. Except for their testimony, they could have been any middle Americans: They were good kids, churchgoing kids, from churchgoing families. But years ago, something was stolen from them by the leaders their families trusted most. As adults, some struggle with alcohol, drugs, depression and suicidal thoughts -- testimony to the destructiveness of child sexual abuse.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 07:59:11 PM
BOSTON
The Cardinal's rebuff
Boston Globe
Editorial: CARDINAL BERNARD Law's rejection of faithful Catholics who want to support the church's charitable activities but not through the archdiocesan hierarchy was remarkable for its clumsiness, even more so for the way it mirrored the church posture earlier this year that alienated so many parishioners.
As with the ongoing sex abuse scandal, church leaders showed far greater concern for their own hierarchy than for the people affected by their actions.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 07:57:31 PM
SUN CITY (FL)
Local Faithful Gather To Voice Church Concerns
Tampa Tribune
By ANDREW MEADOWS
Jul 22, 2002
SUN CITY CENTER - More than 100 people gathered Sunday to discuss problems facing the Roman Catholic Church. It was the inaugural meeting of the Tampa Bay chapter of Voice of the Faithful, a grass-roots group hoping to influence the way the church operates.
The free-form meeting at the Sun City Center town hall complex allowed people to step up to the microphone and speak their minds.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 07:54:37 PM
Will bishops’ new norms pass Vatican scrutiny?
Canonical analysis reveals where the Holy See may have concerns regarding U.S. bishops’ sex-abuse policy

Our Sunday Visitor
By Russell Shaw
When it became known that the president and general secretary of the U.S. bishops’ conference had flown to Rome just 10 days after the bishops met in Dallas, a spokesperson offered a bland explanation for the trip: Bishop Wilton Gregory of Belleville, Ill., was taking a few days away from the office and Msgr. William Fay was on vacation.
Only later was it officially acknowledged that, as everyone knew perfectly well, the two men were launching the effort to sell the bishops’ new policy on clergy sex abuse to the Holy See.
This nervous reluctance to admit the obvious underlines an uncomfortable fact for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) — in some respects, the policy may not be an easy sell. Already, five priests in Chicago are appealing to Rome from their dismissals.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 07:48:33 PM

LOS ANGELES
Payback Time
A new law is expected to unleash a flood of litigation against the L.A. Archdiocese by victims of priestly sex abuse.

New Times
BY RON RUSSELL
More storm clouds are gathering for Cardinal Roger M. Mahony.
Police are investigating at least 72 of his current and former priests for child molestation. New accusers surface almost daily. Despite fierce resistance, a grand jury has forced him to turn over records related to three accused clerics. More subpoenas appear inevitable.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 07:44:02 PM PHOENIX (AZ)
Moral Minority
Bishop Thomas O'Brien is banking on attorney Michael Manning to save the soul of the Phoenix Diocese. The problem: O'Brien still has demons in his office.

Phoenix New Times
BY ROBERT NELSON
In a stunning and welcome reversal, Bishop Thomas O'Brien is now apparently cooperating with the Maricopa County Attorney's investigation of the alleged sexual misconduct of Father Patrick Colleary, whose sins you first read about in this column.
The Phoenix Diocese not only agreed to comply fully with a grand jury subpoena for Colleary's files, but also asked the county attorney to send a broader subpoena seeking all files documenting sexual misconduct with a minor by priests or any diocesan employee.
Since this reversal, O'Brien has removed three priests: Joseph Briceno, Joseph Lessard and Harold Graf. He also promised to move more aggressively in defrocking three of the Valley's most notorious abusers, Mark Lehman, Lan Sherwood and George Bredemann, chronic abusers of children who have been the subjects of several New Times stories dating back to 1989.
O'Brien has also promised to sweep the files of all Catholic churches, schools and other institutions for records of allegations of sexual misconduct. According to O'Brien's new attorney, Mike Manning, the bishop explicitly told his attorneys that any evidence of his own criminal negligence or obstruction should be immediately sent to the county attorney.





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 01:04:18 PM WORCESTER (Mass.)
Kelley faces more charges
The Sentinel and Enterprise
By Robert Mills
WORCESTER -- When Father Robert E. Kelley was arraigned on counts of child rape earlier this year, Diane Gallian was watching.
When Kelley was arraigned Wednesday on an additional count, Diane Gallian was the victim he stood accused of raping.
Kelley, 60, of Worcester, is accused of raping a then 9-year-old Gallian at St. Cecilia's parish in Leominster about 1980, according to a statement from District Attorney John J. Conte.
Kelley, who has already served state prison time in connection with a 1990 conviction for raping a girl in Gardner, was arraigned in June on five counts of unnatural rape of a child in connection with accusations he repeatedly raped Heather Mackey, now 26, of Tewksbury at St. Cecilia's when she was between 4 and 9 years old.
Though a Superior Court judge released Kelley on personal recognizance following his arraignment on the first five counts of child rape, Judge Leina R. Kern ordered him held on $10,000 cash bail after his arraignment Wednesday.
Kelley's attorney, Anthony M. Salerno of Worcester, had been warned that a request for bail would be made, however, and Kelley walked to the clerk of courts office and posted his bond immediately after his arraignment.
Kelley declined to comment on charges against him as a throng of television cameras and reporters followed him down the hallway. One cameraman even crashed into a courthouse wall while walking backwards in front of Kelley.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 08:33:29 AM
NORTH ANDOVER (Mass.)
Voice of Faithful group pushes to fill pews
The Eagle-Tribune
By O'Ryan Johnson and Ethan Forman
Eagle-Tribune Writers
NORTH ANDOVER -- A local chapter of the Voice of the Faithful hopes to refill the pews of area churches, as the lay Catholic group attempts to boost the coffers of charities hit hard by the priest sex abuse scandal.
Catholic Charities says funds from Voice of the Faithful could help keep it afloat, despite Cardinal Bernard F. Law's plan to reject money from the group that formed in response to the scandal.
"We're desperately trying to keep our ministry to the poor going in the midst of all this turmoil," Catholic Charities spokeswoman Maureen March said. "We understand the anger out there."
In the Merrimack Valley, the lay reform group drew 16 new members to its original 35 last night. They came from Haverhill, Methuen, Andover and North Andover to a meeting at St. Michael's Parish Center.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 08:12:29 AM

LOUISVILLE (KY)
Judge orders suit against diocese unsealed; appeal keeps it secret
The Courier-Journal
By Deborah Yetter
dyetter@courier-journal.com
The Courier-Journal
A Fayette Circuit judge yesterday ordered that a lawsuit alleging sexual abuse by priests in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Lexington be unsealed.
But the case remains secret following a preemptive move by lawyers for the diocese.
The diocese yesterday obtained an emergency order from the state Court of Appeals keeping the case under seal until the appeals court can review the ruling of Judge Mary Noble. The diocese is seeking to keep the case secret.
Lawyers for the diocese -- anticipating that Noble would order the case unsealed -- obtained the emergency order even before Noble issued her ruling, according to the order signed by Appeals Court Judge Julia K. Tackett.
An appeals court panel will hear the matter Aug. 5. Tackett's order said that although the Appeals Court in general doesn't block orders before they are issued, it would in this case because Noble had already indicated to parties that she planned to order the suit be unsealed.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:55:37 AM

TORONTO
George speaks of scandal, sin
Chicago Sun-Times
ANNIE SWEENEY STAFF REPORTER
TORONTO--Cardinal Francis George met with young people Wednesday during World Youth Day and talked of the sacrifices and work it takes to be holy and of the consequence of sin within the Catholic Church.
When he arrived at the Catholic festival earlier this week, George had said he was not sure whether he would address the sexual abuse scandals in the church because he wasn't certain participants wanted to discuss it.
The very first question the cardinal fielded was from a 25-year-old from Richmond, Va., who wanted to know how young people can support priests as the scandal unfolds. He spoke of his own priest who was accused but later cleared.
George embraced the opportunity during his talk, or catechesis, to discuss the issue, noting that while some cases are unfounded, there is sin within the church.
"If this whole scandal teaches us anything, it is that there are consequences to very private, very shameful, very hidden, acts," George said. "Sin isn't private."



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:50:42 AM

MANCHESTER (N.H.)
Diocese reaching out
to ease pain of lurid
revelations at St. Pius X

The Union Leader
By KATHRYN MARCHOCKI
Union Leader Staff
Nearly three years ago, St. Pius X parishioners were dealt the devastating blow of losing their beloved pastor, a “people’s priest” whose congenial style infused new life into the Manchester parish.
Now they are reeling from this week’s lurid revelations of the apparent double life led by the late Rev. Richard Connors.
Stricken by a heart attack in a Derry home Nov. 14, 1999, the 56-year-old priest was found wearing a black leather strap wrapped around his genitals and left behind a prescription for Viagra and a rectory loaded with pornography and sexual devices that fellow priests quietly disposed of in a Concord dumpster.
Helping parishioners come to terms with the two faces of Father Connors this weekend will be the Rev. Edward J. Arsenault, current pastor of St. Pius X.
“I’m anguished and dismayed by the same circumstances because I knew Father Connors, too. I knew him as a fine priest,” Arsenault said yesterday.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:33:06 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Archdiocese lawyers say judge should be recused
Boston Herald
by Tom Mashberg
Lawyers for the church will argue in court today that the judge overseeing an apparent settlement in the John J. Geoghan abuse case should consider recusing herself if she cannot ``put aside (her) recollections'' as to whether the deal was struck during talks held in chambers.
Referring to Superior Court Judge Constance Sweeney, church attorneys said, ``the court . . . may be tempted to invoke its own memory'' to try to resolve whether the Archdiocese of Boston committed itself to a settlement.
The lawyers said Sweeney would ``transgress the fundamental norms of the judicial system'' if she were to rely on her memory rather than testimony at a July 31 hearing on the abandoned settlement because her memories could not ``be subject to cross-examination'' by archdiocese lawyers.
In response, plaintiffs' attorney Mitchell Garabedian described the move as an effort to drive Sweeney from the case because she was told by church lawyers they ``had reached a settlement agreement'' with his 86 Geoghan accusers.
``It is the plaintiffs' position the church is seeking an unwarranted recusal of Judge Sweeney,'' he said.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:28:51 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Clergy sex-abuse protesters hold alternate rally for youth
Boston Herald
by Eric Convey
TORONTO - The sex abuse scandal that emanated from Boston earlier this year touched World Youth Day celebrations yesterday, even as organizers of the event officially ignored the troubling issue.
``Clergy sexual abuse is a global crisis,'' declared banners held by protesters taking part in what was billed as an ``alternative youth day.''
``We came to World Youth Day because we know the people (in charge) wouldn't be talking about these things,'' said Tobias Raschke, a German who coordinates youth outreach for the protest group We Are Church.
Yves Manseau, a Canadian who works with victims of sex abuse, expressed disappointment that Pope John Paul II's official emissary to Canada refused to arrange a meeting between the pontiff and survivors of abuse.
``He's here, he's the boss, he's where the buck stops,'' Manseau said.
A letter from the church ambassador to Canada stated that the pope's schedule was already set and noted that he spoke out forcefully against abuse during a visit to the Vatican by U.S. cardinals earlier this year.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:26:47 AM

WORCESTER (Mass.)
Lawsuit: Geoghan was part of sex ring
Boston Herald
by Robin Washington
WORCESTER - Defrocked pedophile priest John J. Geoghan participated in a child sex ring with two other priests run out of Whitinsville's now-closed House of Affirmation, according to a lawsuit filed here Monday.
Geoghan, the late Rev. Victor Frobas and the Rev. David L. Blizard molested Northboro altar boy Robert Malo in the late 1970s, lawyer Tom G. Vukmirovits said in a suit against the Boston Archdiocese and Worcester Diocese.
``He recalls being dropped off (to Geoghan) at a church in Boston by somebody connected with the House of Affirmation,'' Vukmirovits said of the center for troubled priests run by the Rev. Thomas Kane, who fled to Mexico after declaring bankruptcy.
``He put the pieces of the puzzle together when he saw Geoghan on TV,'' Vukmirovits said.
The accusation of a child sex ring echoes that of a settled suit, filed by Mark Barry of Uxbridge, suggesting other priests involved with the House of Affirmation shared boys.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:24:54 AM
WORCESTER (Mass.)
Kelley charged in '90 rape
Worcester Telegram & Gazette
By Richard Nangle
Telegram & Gazette Staff
WORCESTER-- Convicted rapist Rev. Robert E. Kelley was released on $10,000 bail yesterday after pleading not guilty to a sixth new rape charge in Superior Court.
District Attorney John J. Conte told reporters shortly afterward that $10,000 was an appropriate figure that should have been adopted when Rev. Kelley was first arraigned in May.
Yesterday, however, marked the first time the district attorney's office has requested bail be set for Rev. Kelley. He was in- dicted last week on a charge of unnatural rape and abuse of a 9-year-old girl. The incident allegedly occurred in 1990, when Rev. Kelley was serving as priest at St. Cecilia's Catholic Church in Leominster.
Yesterday, the alleged victim, Diane Gallien of Ashburnham, said she was relieved to see the priest was forced to post bail. Several other alleged victims of Rev. Kelley attended the court hearing.
At the May 16 arraignment in Leominster District Court, the first of three recent court dates for Rev. Kelley, Judge Vito A. Virzi set bail at $200,000. His order was vacated later the same day in Worcester Superior Court by Judge Francis R. Fecteau. Rev. Kelley had been arraigned that day on two counts of rape of a child.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:20:40 AM

WORCESTER (Mass.)
Conte will prosecute clergy abuses
Worcester Telegram & Gazette
By Kathleen A. Shaw
Telegram & Gazette Staff
WORCESTER-- District Attorney John J. Conte said yesterday he expects more prosecutions in the current clergy sexual abuse scandal and has received reports of past abuses from several religious denominations.
He declined to say who is under investigation, which is his longstanding policy, but said he expects more criminal charges to be brought against clergy.
Mr. Conte said he has had to add two more state police troopers to his staff to handle the number of clergy abuse investigations in progress. “We do prosecute and we are prosecuting priests,” he said.
The Worcester grand jury last week returned another indictment against the Rev. Robert E. Kelley, who was accused of child rape and was arraigned yesterday in Worcester Superior Court. Rev. Kelley is facing child rape charges of another girl and has been named in three recent civil suits by a total of eight female victims.
Six active priests have been removed from their parishes by the Catholic Diocese of Worcester since February. Mr. Conte said reports on each of them were made to his office.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:18:20 AM

PORTLAND (ME)
New Catholic investigator: Sense of duty will guide me
Portland Press Herald
By JOSIE HUANG, Portland Press Herald Writer
It was never easy investigating colleagues in the Portland Police Department, but a strong sense of duty helped former deputy police chief John Brennan get over any discomfort.
Brennan, who is now a Catholic deacon, said the same obligation to the public will guide him as he conducts internal investigations for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland.
"It's important that whether you work for the police department or church, that that organization have a high level of integrity with the public," said Brennan, who has begun investigating both old and new complaints as director of the diocese' new Office of Professional Responsibility.
His is a job stacked with responsibility and dogged by revelations this year that church leaders in Maine and beyond had ignored allegations of abuses by priests. It's not that Brennan, a lifelong Catholic, minds the load: Retired from police work and ordained a deacon in 1998, he said he sees his new role as an opportunity to help repair the damage the church has sustained.
But victims' advocates and laity critical of church policies say Brennan's ties to the diocese blemish his appointment.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/25/2002 07:15:01 AM
Head of US panel wants priests' fates put in local hands
Boston Globe
By Sacha Pfeiffer, Globe Staff, 7/25/2002
In an apparent retreat from his earlier statements, Governor Frank Keating of Oklahoma, who heads a national panel charged with monitoring the Catholic Church's handling of clergy sex abuse, said yesterday that it will be the job of local review boards, not his panel, to recommend the removal of top church officials who protected abusive priests.
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:43:35 AM
Bishops Select Lay Board on Sexual Abuse Review
The New York Times
By LAURIE GOODSTEIN
The nation's Roman Catholic bishops announced yesterday the appointment of a sexual abuse review board composed entirely of active Catholic laypeople, including some who work for church organizations, but no one from the victims' advocacy groups that have been most critical of the church.
Among members are Leon E. Panetta, former chief of staff for the Clinton White House; Dr. Paul R. McHugh; former chairman of the department of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine; and Nicholas Cafardi, the dean of Duquesne University Law School in Pittsburgh who has been legal counsel to several church bodies.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:41:54 AM
TORONTO
Dissidents in Toronto Attack Catholic Church
Yahoo! News
Wed Jul 24, 3:17 PM ET
By Christopher Noble
TORONTO (Reuters) - As tens of thousands of young Roman Catholics gathered in Toronto on Wednesday, bubbling over with enthusiasm for their church, a small but vocal groups of critics urged reform and attacked the church hierarchy for ignoring a damaging child sex abuse scandal.
"We want to bring light to some of the burning issues in the world that the Catholic Church has been trying to shove under the rug," said Milton Chan, a member of Challenge the Church, which is pushing young Catholics in Toronto for World Youth Day to critically examine the church's teachings.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:25:18 AM
Eight more are named to abuse review panel
St. Louis Post Dispatch
BY PATRICIA RICE
Post-Dispatch Religion Writer
Bishop Wilton D. Gregory, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, has announced most of the members of the board that will monitor how the nation's 192 Catholic dioceses deal with allegations of sexual abuse by priests.
The national review board will run a new Office for Child and Youth Protection. It also will publicize flaws in local diocesan sexual abuse review boards.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:21:58 AM
BALTIMORE
Baltimore judge rejects Stokes' lawyer's attempt to be removed from case
Brown says family of his client opposed highly publicized tactics

Baltimore Sun
By Allison Klein
Sun Staff
July 24, 2002
A Baltimore judge rejected yesterday a request by attorney Warren A. Brown to relinquish one of his more noted cases - that involving Dontee Stokes, the man charged with shooting a city priest two months ago.
Brown, a vociferous lawyer known for representing some of Maryland's most high-profile defendants, made a formal request in Baltimore Circuit Court to drop Stokes as a client. He said he made the request after Stokes' family protested Brown's publicity-seeking style.
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:16:32 AM
SEATTLE
Archdiocese sued again; 7 more people claim abuse by priest
Seattle Times
By Ray Rivera
Seattle Times staff reporter
Seven more people sued the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Seattle yesterday, alleging the Rev. James McGreal had sexually abused them as children. It was the third suit to be filed against McGreal since May, all in King County Superior Court, on behalf of 14 alleged victims.
McGreal, who served in at least 10 parishes and two hospitals in the archdiocese between 1948 and 1988, resigned in 1988 after parishioners learned of his continued history of molesting children. A lawsuit filed by another victim in Clallam County in 1994 was settled, and the terms were not disclosed.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/25/2002 06:13:03 AM

Wednesday, July 24, 2002



WORCESTER (Mass.)
D.A. says investigation did not substantiate charges
The Catholic Free Press
By Kevin Luperchio
A 2 1/2-month-long investigation by the district attorney’s office and the diocese has failed to substantiate allegations that Bishop Rueger sexually molested a 13-year-old altar boy at Our Lady of Lourdes Parish in the early 1960s.
Bishop Rueger firmly denied the allegations last Friday at a press conference in the plaza in front of the Chancery. He did so with the support of Bishop Reilly, who also spoke at the press conference. Joining him in support in the plaza were clergy and staff at the Chancery.
Sime J. Braio, now 52, filed a civil suit July 10 in Worcester Superior Court claiming he was molested while he was at Our Lady of Lourdes Parish and later while he was at the Lyman School for Boys in Westboro.
“These allegations are totally unfounded,” Bishop Rueger said. “What the allegations cite 40 years ago never happened.”
Dist. Atty John Conte said in a telephone interview last Friday that State Police assigned to his office took a lengthy statement from Mr. Braio. His office then conducted an extensive investigation into Mr. Braio’s allegations over about 2 1/2 months. He said they were not able to substantiate Mr. Braio’s charges.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 10:34:24 PM

WORCESTER (Mass.)
Diocese rallies for Bishop Rueger
The Catholic Free Press
By Kevin Luperchio and Tanya Connor
Parishioners have showered Bishop Rueger with overwhelming support after he declared himself innocent of a claim that he sexually abused a young parishioner 40 years ago.
Bishop Reilly, in an open letter to parishioners released last weekend, noted that Bishop Rueger, in a press conference Friday, “vehemently denied that there was any truth to the allegation being made, yet he did so calmly and with a sense of Christian charity.”
Bishop Reilly invited parishioners to put their “faith into action and voice your support for Bishop Rueger. From the media to your friends and neighbors, take a stand for those whose lives and reputations are being so callously treated without cause and reason.”
Father Cornelius F. O’Leary, pastor of St. Martin’s Parish in the Otter River section of Templeton, organized a Mass Monday specifically to pray for Bishop Rueger.
“He’s been accused wrongly of sexual abuse,” Father O’Leary told the congregation.
“Bishop Rueger we love you and we’re here to ask God’s help for you and all the bishops of the church,” he said.
“The cross is here,” he said. He asked the congregation to give the bishop a hand and they applauded heartily.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 10:31:30 PM
LEOMINSTER (Mass.)
Former Leominster priest denies raping 9-year-old girl
Boston.com
By Associated Press
WORCESTER, Mass. -- A former priest who was jailed 12 years ago for sexually abusing a child faces new charges that he raped another girl.
Robert E. Kelley, 60, was released Wednesday on $10,000 cash bail after pleading innocent in Worcester Superior Court to sexually abusing a 9-year-old girl between May and July of 1980, when he was a priest at St. Cecilia's Parish in Leominster, said Elizabeth Stammo, a spokeswoman for Worcester District Attorney John Conte.
Kelley has been criminally charged with sexually assaulting six girls in separate lawsuits, Stammo said. Each case is scheduled for an Aug. 27 pretrial conference, she said.
Kelley's lawyer, Anthony Salerno, did not immediately return a telephone call from The Associated Press on Wednesday.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 04:05:22 PM

Catholic bishops' president adds eight new members to monitoring board
Boston.com
By Richard N. Ostling, Associated Press, 07/24/02
The president of the U.S. Roman Catholic bishops appointed eight people Wednesday -- including a former chief of staff in the Clinton White House -- to a review board that will monitor American church leaders as they implement the new clerical sex abuse policy.
Leon Panetta, former congressman and White House chief of staff, was among those chosen by Bishop Wilton D. Gregory.
Gregory previously chose Oklahoma Gov. Frank Keating as board chairman and three initial members: prominent Washington attorney Robert S. Bennett; Anne M. Burke of Chicago, a justice on the Illinois Appellate Court; and Michael J. Bland, a victim of clergy abuse and a psychological counselor who works with victims for the Chicago Archdiocese.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 03:57:19 PM

LAWRENCE (Mass.)
Church won't take group's donations
Lawrence Eagle-Tribune
By Mark Vogler
Eagle-Tribune Writer
Local Catholics active in a movement to reform the church after the clergy sex scandal say they are disappointed and discouraged by Cardinal Bernard F. Law's decision not to accept charitable donations from the group.
Law said yesterday the Archdiocese of Boston will not accept money from Voice of the Faithful, a Roman Catholic reform group whose new fund would allow Catholics to give directly to church charities. Some archdiocese-related groups like Catholic Charities also plan to reject donations from the group, church officials said.
The lay reform has proposed creating a so-called Voice of Compassion fund that would bypass the church hierarchy and give directly to archdiocese charities.
"To me, it doesn't make any sense for him not to accept the money that so many people desperately need," John Vellante of North Andover, Mass., said today.
"I can't speak for the group. But I'm sure the reaction will be one of disappointment. It will be a topic of conversation tonight when our chapter meets," he said. The local group has an organizational meeting planned at St. Michael's Parish in North Andover.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 08:03:58 AM
The Need For Truth On Gay Priests
The Washington Post
Column By E. J. Dionne Jr.
Tuesday, July 23, 2002; Page A17
When you're in the middle of a scandal, there is nothing like somebody else's scandal to knock yours off the front pages. So it's just possible that at least a few leaders of the Roman Catholic Church have been saying quiet prayers of thanksgiving for the guys down at WorldCom. Mammon's strong run in recent weeks has bought the church some breathing space.
But the nation's bishops must know that they won't be able to ride out the pedophilia scandal under the cover of Wall Street crashes and shenanigans. The problems the scandal has brought to the surface are still much on the minds of the faithful.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/24/2002 07:50:58 AM
LOUISVILLE (KY)
Report says priest confessed sex abuse
Molestations began in 1960, according to court documents

The Courier-Journal
By Andrew Wolfson and Gregory A. Hall
The Courier-Journal
The Rev. Louis E. Miller first molested a child in 1960 and confessed it soon after to a superior, according to a psychiatric report filed Monday in Jefferson Circuit Court.
The March 1990 psychiatric evaluation says that Miller continued to molest children as often as every other month over the next two decades and ''was moved from one position to another when these incidents have come to the authorities' attention.''
The report, which was prepared by a Cincinnati psychiatrist and sent to Archbishop Thomas C. Kelly, said ''Miller admits to periodically acting out sexual impulses in this manner his entire adult life,'' mostly involving boys 10 to 15.
Miller, 71, was indicted last month in Jefferson County on charges alleging he sexually abused 15 children, and in Oldham County last week on charges of indecent or immoral practices with eight children in the St. Aloysius parish in Pewee Valley. He has pleaded innocent in both counties.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 07:31:34 AM
RICHMOND (VA)
The credibility problem of bishop's investigation
The Virginian-Pilot
Forget, for a moment, whether a Richmond area Roman Catholic priest is guilty of the serious sexual abuse allegations leveled against him.
Forget, too, that the allegations stem from long-ago incidents against the Rev. John E. Leonard, when he was on the staff of the now-closed St. John Vianney Seminary in Goochland. At least three men have claimed wrongdoing by Leonard in disgusting incidents. Leonard, 63, has repeatedly denied the allegations.
The more serious issues for the Catholic Diocese of Richmond are: Did Bishop Walter F. Sullivan follow the proper procedures in investigating the incidents and getting recommendations from a diocesan panel about the probe? And did Bishop Sullivan use a more lenient standard in dealing with Leonard, the former principal of Norfolk Catholic High School?



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 07:20:49 AM
CLEVELAND
Bishop Quinn's tarnished star
07/23/02
The Plain Dealer
Editorial: Details of how Auxiliary Bishop A. James Quinn undermined a progressive sexual abuse policy in 1985 - a policy that might have prevented the scandal that erupted this year - is the final straw.
As an auxiliary bishop of the Cleveland Catholic Diocese, Quinn has dishonored his position and his faith, and has compromised his credibility. Surely, Northeast Ohio's Catholics can have little trust in him.
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/24/2002 06:58:22 AM
MILWAUKEE
Weakland won't be charged over hush money
Donor tied to cash source didn't have restrictions on use at time, but did later

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel
By GINA BARTON and MARIE ROHDE
of the Journal Sentinel staff
July 22, 2002
Most of the money paid to stop a man from going public with sexual abuse claims against former Milwaukee Archbishop Rembert G. Weakland came from benefactors who have said they don't want their donations used that way.
The investigation into the source of the $450,000 settlement with Paul Marcoux also determined that Weakland should not face criminal charges as a result of the payout, state and federal authorities said Monday.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/24/2002 06:55:20 AM

MANCHESTER (N.H.)
Lawsuit against N.H. bishop alleges
Church leaders destroyed child pornography found at dead priest’s home

Foster's Democrat
By J.M. HIRSCH
Associated Press Writer
CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — A Roman Catholic priest filed a lawsuit Tuesday accusing Bishop John B. McCormack of waging a campaign to keep him silent about the discovery of a dead priest’s pornography collection.
The Rev. James A. MacCormack sued the Diocese of Manchester, McCormack and other church officials seeking undisclosed damages, saying they derailed his career to avoid a scandal.
The diocesan chancellor, the Rev. Edward Arsenault, denied the allegations and accused MacCormack of digging for money.
"We are deeply saddened that a priest has chosen to attempt to capitalize on the death of a fellow priest for personal gain," Arsenault said.
MacCormack and his lawyer, Robert McDaniel, have pressured the church for money through "a series of threats to expose the difficult circumstances of the death of a priest in exchange for financial consideration," he said.
McDaniel denied his client was motivated by money, saying he wants to "clean up the sordid and reprehensible pattern of lies and deceptions. That’s what he’s motivated by. At no point ever was there the slightest suggestion by anyone that our client’s silence could be purchased."
McDaniel also said he informed the state attorney general’s office and federal investigators about the case because his client alleges church officials destroyed the child pornography, which could have been evidence of a crime. Attorney General Philip McLaughlin would not comment on whether his office was investigating.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:52:00 AM

JAFFREY (N.H.)
Rev. MacCormack faced
demotion and transfer

The Union Leader
By STEPHEN SEITZ And MARK HAYWARD
Union Leader News
JAFFREY — Rather than accept demotion and transfer, the Rev. James A. MacCormack faced the parish at St. Patrick Church this spring and told parishioners he was taking a break.
MacCormack, who is now making allegations about a dead priest’s child pornography collection, was facing allegations himself back then, according to a May 16 article in the Monadnock Ledger.
The Peterborough-based weekly newspaper reported that a handful of people had accused MacCormack of abusing his dog, holding BYOB parties with women in the rectory, punching holes in rectory walls, not working well with women and creating a hostile work environment.
“They were all nonsense,” said Michael Neyens, past president of the church’s pastoral council, last night. The allegations came from a church employee whom MacCormack had fired, Neyens said.
“The dog adores him,” Neyens said. “He (MacCormack) would sooner cut off his arm than smack the dog.”
Neyens said MacCormack punched holes in walls while he was rewiring the building.





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:40:31 AM
MANCHESTER (N.H.)
Priest alleges porn found at
St. Pius X rectory, covered up

The Union Leader
From Staff and Wire Reports
A priest sued Bishop John B. McCormack and other church officials yesterday, alleging they ruined his career to keep him silent about the circumstances of another priest’s death and the subsequent removal of “dozens of plastic garbage bags” of pornography from the St. Pius X rectory in Manchester.
The Rev. James A. “Seamus” MacCormack accused the church of shunting him off to a rural parish and forcing him to seek psychiatric help because church leaders feared he would disclose what he knew about the 1999 death of the Rev. Richard Connors — just as the church’s child sex abuse scandal exploded into the headlines earlier this year.
The lawsuit says the case began Nov. 15, 1999, when MacCormack helped authorities identify the body of Connors, 56, who had died of a heart attack the night before at the home of two men. Connors was a much-beloved pastor at St. Pius and credited with turning the parish around.
According to the lawsuit and police records, viewed by the Associated Press, Connors was partially clothed at the time of death and had a black leather device tied around his genitals. The two men told authorities Connors had come to the house to buy a dog.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:31:25 AM

WORCESTER (Mass.)
Rev. Kelley to be arraigned on rape charge
Worcester Telegram & Gazette
By Kathleen A. Shaw
Telegram & Gazette Staff
WORCESTER-- The Rev. Robert E. Kelley will be arraigned at 9 a.m. today in Worcester Superior Court on a charge of unnatural rape of a 9-year-old girl. The alleged victim has not been identified.
The incident allegedly occurred several years ago when Rev. Kelley was serving as a Catholic priest at St. Cecilia's parish in Leominster. Rev. Kelley was indicted by the grand jury last week.
Elizabeth Stammo, spokeswoman for District Attorney John J. Conte, said Rev. Kelley is also due back to the court today for a pretrial conference on five other rape charges involving Heather Mackey of Tewksbury.
Rev. Kelley, who was not defrocked but has not functioned as a priest since 1986, has been free on personal recognizance.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:26:13 AM

WORCESTER (Mass.)
Suit claims priests ran sex ring
Worcester Telegram & Gazette
By Kathleen A. Shaw
Telegram & Gazette Staff
WORCESTER-- A child sexual abuse ring involving the Rev. John Geoghan of the Boston archdiocese, the Rev. David L. Blizard and the late Rev. Victor Frobas of the Worcester diocese and others, operated from the former House of Affirmation in Whitinsville, according to a lawsuit filed Monday in Worcester Superior Court.
The suit also names the Worcester diocese, the Boston archdiocese and its Auxiliary Bishop Thomas Daily, who was also chancellor in Boston at the time of the alleged incidents.
The allegation was made by Robert Malo, formerly of Northboro, who received settlements in the mid-1990s from the Worcester and Wheeling/ harleston, W. Va., dioceses regarding alleged abuse by Rev. Frobas, who has since died, and the Rev. Thomas A. Kane.
These incidents in the latest suit are said to have occurred from 1978 to 1980. Rev. Blizard, a native of Whitinsville, was assigned to Our Lady Immaculate parish in Athol at the time. Rev. Frobus was at St. Rose of Lima in Northboro. Rev. Geoghan was in the Boston archdiocese and Rev. Kane was executive director of the House of Affirmation.
According to the suit, “....the House of Affirmation Inc. contained a 'child sex ring' whereby young children were subjected to repeated sexual abuse.”
The House of Affirmation was founded by Rev. Kane and the late Sister Anna Polcino, a religious sister who was also a psychiatrist. The House was founded to provide treatment for priests and religious for a variety of psychological problems, including sexual issues.
Rev. Kane, the subject of a past suit alleging sexual abuse of a 9-year-old boy, was last known to be in Mexico. He operated as a therapist at the House based on a bogus doctoral degree. He also served as executive director.
The House, which operated independently but had the support of bishops and cardinals locally and throughout the country, closed in 1987 amid a financial scandal.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:22:52 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Church open to discussion on donations
Boston Herald
by Tom Mashberg
A church spokesman said yesterday that Archdiocese of Boston officials are now willing to sit down and talk money with the lay group the Voice of the Faithful.
But he said the church expected Catholic Charities and other quasi-independent Boston-area Catholic philanthropies to move formally to reject VOTF donations unless Bernard Cardinal Law says otherwise.
``If a meeting with VOTF can happen, that would be welcome,'' the Rev. Christopher J. Coyne said.
He added that remarks in the Herald yesterday by a key VOTF member regarding Law's ``pastoral role'' in choosing where charitable money goes ``were very positive.''
``But we are sure for now that the separately incorporated Catholic groups are on board with us in saying no,'' Coyne said, ``because as of now the VOTF fund circumvents the normal relationship the groups have with the archbishop.''
VOTF issued no formal reaction yesterday to the archdiocese's decision to reject money from its fund, dubbed ``Voice of Compassion-Boston'' and administered by the National Catholic Community Foundation. But officials familiar with the effort said fund raising was well under way, and that at least $10,000 has already been pledged by local VOTF founders.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:17:13 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
The politics of giving
Boston Globe
By Eileen McNamara, Globe Columnist
Skip the middle men, all of them.
Sister Margaret Leonard will take your money. She is not in the habit of turning down donations to Project Hope, the food-shelter/education-and-training program she runs for homeless families in Dorchester.
Bridget Shaheen won't send your money back, either. She needs it to operate Lazarus House, the emergency shelter/food pantry/soup kitchen/job training program she directs in Lawrence.
And, count on my cousin Debbie Chausee to cash any check made payable to the House of Hope, the family shelter and substance abuse program she operates in Lowell. The former Sister of Notre Dame could use the help for the 18 families her program houses and feeds.
Your donations need not go begging if the clergy sex abuse scandal has undermined your confidence in the integrity of the hierarchy of the Catholic Church. There is no shortage of programs, with Catholic roots and ecumenical hearts, that would be happy to take your money if you are more interested in helping the poor than in making a political statement about power and its sundry abuses by the man on Lake Street.
Cardinal Bernard F. Law this week is giving Voice of the Faithful an object lesson in the limits of conciliation. You can't negotiate with a man who won't come to the table. The archbishop of Boston says he does not want the $10,000 raised for the poor by the polite folks in the grass-roots reform movement who gathered almost 5,000 strong at the Hynes Convention Center last Saturday. The price, having to answer to the laity for the use of that money, is just too high for a man hanging onto power by a fingernail.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:10:39 AM
BOSTON (Mass.)
In rift with Law, agency to accept lay group's funds
Boston Globe
By Stephen Kurkjian and Michael Rezendes, Globe Staff
In a rebuff to Cardinal Bernard F. Law, officials with Catholic Charities, the principal social service agency for the Boston Archdiocese, said yesterday that the organization will accept donations from the newly formed lay group Voice of the Faithful and criticized Law for rejecting the group's fund-raising plan for church schools and programs that benefit the urban poor.
''We will not turn down any donation,'' declared Maureen March, the spokeswoman for Catholic Charities.
On Monday, church officials said Law would not cooperate with Voice of the Faithful's proposal to raise money from Catholics boycotting the annual Cardinal's Appeal due to the clergy sexual abuse scandal, because the plan did not recognize Law's role and responsibility in funding church programs. Church officials also said Catholic Charities and Caritas Christi, the Catholic health care network founded by Law, had also agreed to reject Voice of the Faithful donations.
But yesterday, prominent Catholics, several priests, and board members at Catholic Charities said they were shocked by Law's decision and vowed to support Voice of the Faithful's plan.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:06:44 AM

PORTLAND (ME)
Diocese identifies new support person for sex-abuse victims
Portland Press Herald
By Associated Press
The new outreach professional hired to help victims of sexual abuse by Roman Catholic priests in Maine said she has been contacted by some victims and she hopes more will seek her out.
Susanne Sturm, whose hiring was announced Tuesday, said she does not know how many victims there are in Maine, but she already has been contacted by "more than 10" since she began her duties on July 1.
She hopes to provide pastoral support to victims, direct them to professional counseling when needed, and assist in setting up support groups for those willing to go that route. She also will coordinate any future meetings between survivors of sexual abuse and the bishop.
In effect, Sturm will be the firm point of contact in the Portland Diocese for victims seeking ongoing support. "If it can start with me, then I'd be privileged to start (that process)," Sturm said from her Bangor home.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/24/2002 06:01:51 AM

Tuesday, July 23, 2002


EVANSVILLE (IN)
Celestine parish fighting for priest
Courier & Press
By JUDY DAVIS Courier & Press staff writer 464-7593 or jdavis@evansville.net
CELESTINE, Ind. - The Rev. Michael Allen has bid farewell to his parish, but those who attend the small church want him back.
Allen stood before his congregation in St. Peter Celestine Catholic Church on May 5 and confessed a sexual relationship with a then 16-year-old boy in 1976.
Later, the congregation of more than 400 people responded with a standing ovation when Evansville Diocese Bishop Gerald Gettelfinger announced that it was his intention for Allen to remain as their priest.
Gettelfinger's intention, however, was made moot by a "zero tolerance" policy on clergy sex abuse, passed at a recent conference of bishops in Dallas. Under that policy, Allen can no longer take part in any ministry that involved contact with parishioners.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/23/2002 07:54:18 PM
BOSTON
Is 'Voice of the Faithful' Unfaithful to Catholic Principles?
Massachusetts News
MassNews Staff
The largest story on the front page of yesterday's Boston Globe was about the lay reform group known as "Voice of the Faithful" which met on Saturday at the Hynes Auditorium with 4,000 people from across the country in attendance.
The group started in Wellesley in the basement of St. John the Evangelist Church just five months ago, after the sexual scandals appeared. It was begun by a well known activist, cardiologist James E. Muller, who was a member of a group which won the Nobel peace prize in 1985 for its work against U.S. policy on the nuclear bomb,
posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/23/2002 07:50:20 PM

ADAMS (Mass.)
Ex-Adams priest accused of sex abuse
North Adams Transcript
By Donna Roberts
North Adams Transcript
ADAMS -- The Rev. Francis P. Lavelle who served at St. Thomas Aquinas Church for nine years is being accused by two men of sexually abusing them when they were minors.
Lavelle was pastor of St. Mary Church in Longmeadow when the charges were filed in Hampden Superior Court Tuesday, July 16, against him and the Diocese of Springfield. According to Lavelle's lawyer, Daniel M. Kelly of Springfield, Lavelle denies the allegations and is prepared to defend himself if and when he and the Roman Catholic bishop are served the charges.
"He specifically states that these are false allegations of sexual misconduct for which he has a very substantial affirmative defense," Kelly told the Springfield Union News last Wednesday.
K. Kristopher Kane, 45, currently of Oakland Mills, Pa., said he was molested by Lavelle at age 15 when he was assigned to Holy Trinity Parish in Greenfield in 1972. The second man, identified as a New York City lawyer who filed suit under the pseudonym John Doe, claimed Lavelle sexually assaulted him twice in one day in 1980. At that time, Lavelle was working as a secretary for the Most Rev. Joseph F. Maguire, who was bishop of the Springfield Diocese.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 11:13:19 AM CLEVELAND
The churchman at scandal's heart
The Plain Dealer
07/21/02
By James F. McCarty
Plain Dealer Reporter
The scandal over sexually abusive priests has sustained much of its shocking power by showing the world two contradictory faces of the Roman Catholic Church.
For much of this year, the church's preferred image - as a loving, pastoral community, an educator of youths and a compassionate minister to the poor - has been overshadowed by a darker picture: that of a secretive, cynical and self-serving bureaucracy bent on protecting abusers at the expense of their young victims.
And probably no churchman in America - with the possible exception of embattled Cardinal Bernard Law of Boston - has come to personify that split personality more succinctly than Auxiliary Bishop Alexander James Quinn of the Diocese of Cleveland. To his friends and those who have known him since his youth on Cleveland's West Side, the 70-year-old Quinn is cherished as a kind-hearted, charming, pious priest with a devotion to the less fortunate and a love of the outdoors.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/23/2002 07:42:22 AM

MANCHESTER (N.H.)
Rev. Doyle to assist
in NH sex abuse suits

The Union Leader
By KATHRYN MARCHOCKI
Union Leader Staff
The Rev. Tom Doyle addresses a crowd at the Voice of the Faithful national conference, in Boston on Saturday. Catholics from across the country attended the meeting in Boston to discuss the sex abuse scandal that has shaken their church. Doyle spoke on, among other topics, restructuring the Catholic Church.
A leading Catholic church expert recently honored for his unwavering efforts to address the problem of child sexual abuse by clergy will assist New Hampshire lawyers representing alleged victims here.
The Rev. Thomas P. Doyle, a Dominican priest and canon lawyer, will serve as an expert witness for the approximate 110 men and women who claim they were molested by clerics in the Diocese of Manchester as far back as the 1950s, attorney Peter E. Hutchins said yesterday.
“It is a tremendous boost to the cases here in New Hampshire in that we now have a world-renowned expert in this field who is also a Roman Catholic priest,” added the Manchester attorney, who has filed a class action lawsuit against the diocese.
Doyle, 57, was honored Saturday by Voice of the Faithful, a grassroots group of about 19,000 lay Catholics that presented him with its first Priest of Integrity Award at its national conference in Boston.





posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:26:11 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Church rejects critics' money: Donations from grassroots group spurned
Boston Herald
by Tom Mashberg and Robin Washington
The Archdiocese of Boston said yesterday it would reject donations from a lay Catholic group seeking to set up an independent fund for disaffected faithful who no longer want to give money to the cardinal's annual appeal.
The decision came even before the burgeoning organization Voice of the Faithful had finalized plans for raising money for 80 or so Bay State charities that benefit from the Cardinal's Appeal drive.
``The archdiocese cannot accept this initiative,'' the chancery said in a statement, ``because it undercuts . . . the Cardinal's Appeal.''




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:20:45 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Protester tells of embracing cardinal
Boston Globe
By Kevin Graham, Globe Correspondent
Arthur Austin says he arrived at Holy Cross Cathedral Sunday wearing a ''Reject Cardinal Law'' button, intending to stay outside with other protesters.
But Austin, who says he is a victim of sexual abuse by the Rev. Paul Shanley, says he ended up taking communion from Cardinal Bernard F. Law for the first time and even sharing an emotional embrace with the archbishop.
Austin, of Braintree, recalled yesterday how he entered the cathedral in the South End and prayed intensely. ''And when it came time for the Eucharist, I stood up,'' he said.
Soon Austin found himself standing in front of the man he said he blames for the sex abuse scandal. When Law saw the button he winced, said Austin.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:15:55 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Pope's trip to North America provides test and testament
Boston Globe
By Michael Paulson, Globe Staff
His body is frail. The American Catholic church is in crisis. The number of young adults registered to come see him is well below expectations.
But an undaunted Pope John Paul II is still globetrotting, even during a summer when he is so weak that for the first time he has acceded to his doctors' wishes and canceled his weekly visit to the Vatican from his summer home at Castel Gandolfo.
The 82-year-old pontiff is scheduled to arrive in Toronto today to begin an 11-day trip to Canada, Guatemala, and Mexico. In Toronto, he will lead young adults from around the world in a celebration of Catholicism called World Youth Day; in Guatemala City and Mexico City he will name two saints.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:12:47 AM
MILWAUKEE (Wisc.)
Former Archbishop Cleared in Sex-Case Fund
The New York Times
By REUTERS
MILWAUKEE (Reuters) — Prosecutors said today that they had found no evidence of criminal wrongdoing in a $450,000 payment by former Archbishop Rembert G. Weakland of Milwaukee to a man who had accused him of sexual abuse.
The United States attorney in Milwaukee, Steven Biskupic, and District Attorney E. Michael McCann of Milwaukee County issued a statement saying they were closing an inquiry that they began shortly after Archbishop Weakland's disclosure in May about the payment.
"No evidence that was reviewed establishes that the archdiocese obtained funds through misrepresentations on how those funds would be used," the statement said, adding that no evidence showed that the money was "obtained from contributions previously dedicated to other purposes."
The two officials said the money came from an account that had the proceeds of real estate sales. At the time the payment was made in 1998, they said, the account contained nearly $1 million from the sale of an office building that had been donated to the archdiocese with no strings attached.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:07:10 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Archdiocese to Refuse Gifts That Thwart Bishop's Power
The New York Times
By PAM BELLUCK
BOSTON — The Archdiocese of Boston said today that it would refuse donations from a charitable fund set up to let people give to Roman Catholic causes while bypassing the archdiocese's financial control.
The group, Voice of the Faithful, a fast-growing organization formed by Boston-area lay Catholics in response to the clergy sexual abuse scandal, had said it would begin raising money last weekend at its first convention, attended by 4,000 people from around the country.
The intention of the group's Voice of Compassion fund was to maintain contributions to many programs that are supported by the archdiocese's annual fund-raising drive, the Cardinal's Appeal, including programs to help inner-city parishes, people with disabilities and patients recuperating in hospitals.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/23/2002 06:03:44 AM

Monday, July 22, 2002



Loyal opposition
Garry Wills, historian and papal critic, explains why he stays Catholic

San Francisco Chronicle
Reviewed by Joseph Di Prisco
He is an entertainingly acerbic and witty writer about a subject as serious as life and death. The catch is that, for him -- standing in loyal opposition to Rome -- it is more serious than life and death. He inveighs against the current hierarchy's "silly" rejection of contraception and female priests, its refusal to revisit clerical celibacy, its cover-up of priest pedophilia. He makes clear that the attempt to buttress the status quo ante is, while historically explicable, indefensible and misguided. Nonetheless, the disingenuousness of these practices and positions does not undercut his faith. If that sounds like a miracle, it is only one of many distinguishing "Why I Am a Catholic."
posted by Jayson Landeza on 7/22/2002 11:19:06 PM

RICHMOND (VA)
Support for priest strong
Parishioners want closure at St. Michael

Richmond Times-Dispatch
BY LISA HOPPENJANS
TIMES-DISPATCH STAFF WRITER
Though questions about the reinstatement of a priest accused of sexual impropriety still lurk in the minds of many - including some members of a diocesan sexual-abuse panel - support among the priest's parishioners remains strong.
The Most Rev. Walter F. Sullivan, bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Richmond, reinstated the Rev. John Leonard to St. Michael Church in Glen Allen last month without sufficient consultation from the panel established to review sexual-abuse complaints, some members said.
Parishioners, however, said they're ready for closure.
"The bishop has dealt with it," said Shirley Cadden, who has attended St. Michael Church for almost 10 years. "We love [Leonard], and we're glad he's back - I think it's settled for most people."
At yesterday's 11 a.m. service, Leonard made only passing reference to the controversy over the decision.
"My picture's been in the paper more than Joe Morrissey's," Leonard joked, in his sole allusion to the panel's complaints.
Controversial defense attorney Morrissey made headlines this week when a jury awarded more than $1 million dollars to the man who sued him for as- sault and battery.
In May, three of Leonard's former students told an investigative team Leonard had engaged in sexually inappropriate behavior about 30 years ago when he was on the faculty of St. John Vianney Seminary, then a diocesan high school for boys interested in the priesthood.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 09:40:09 PM
Father Groeschel on the Scandals:
Where to Go From Here

National Catholic Register
June 14-20, 2002
by JOHN BURGER
Register Staff Writer
With a doctorate in psychology from Columbia University, Franciscan Friar of the Renewal Father Benedict Groeschel has worked with priests in difficulties at a retreat house in the Archdiocese of New York. Through the years he has interviewed more than 400 men who have left the priesthood and helped 85 return.
He has written a new book on the recent sexual-abuse scandals in the Church, From Scandal to Hope, in which he issues a call for reform and renewal. Catholics must either "move definitively toward reform or … go back into even deeper mediocrity and confusion," he writes.
Archbishop-designate Timothy Dolan of Milwaukee, writing in the preface, calls Father Groeschel "a man with a keen spiritual and pastoral sense."
Father Groeschel spoke with Register staff writer John Burger about his book and about what the Church needs to do to recover.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 09:16:20 PM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Archdiocese opposes reform group's donation plan
Boston.com
By Ron DePasquale, Associated Press
BOSTON -- The Archdiocese of Boston said Monday it has directed its charities to refuse donations from a non-clergy reform group whose fund would allow Catholics to give money directly to church charities.
Voice of the Faithful, a group borne out of the Catholic priest sex abuse scandal, proposed its fund to bypass the Cardinal's Appeal -- Cardinal Bernard Law's annual fund-raising effort -- and give directly to archdiocese charities.
"An initiative opposed to the Cardinal's Appeal, something that takes the bishop completely out of the loop, is not allowable," said the Rev. Christopher Coyne, an archdiocese spokesman.
The archdiocese needs to "maintain the proper relationship between a bishop and the faithful," Law spokeswoman Donna Morrissey said in a prepared statement.
The group was "a little confused" by the announcement because it had not fully explained the fund to the archdiocese, said Voice spokesman Mike Emerton.
"If the Cardinal's Appeal is down 30 to 40 percent, and programs have to be closed, and the public knows there's a pool of money waiting that the laity contributed to make sure organizations are up and running, and the archdiocese flat out refuses to accept it, that would be a very unfortunate situation," Emerton said.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 08:34:32 PM
AMARILLO (TX)
Bishop says diocese followed procedures
Amarillo Globe-News
By DON MUNSCH
dmunsch@amarillonet.com
Bishop John W. Yanta of the Diocese of Amarillo said Friday he was aware of priests who worked here who had sexual misconduct records in their backgrounds, but that "we worked with the committee that was working with these priests, psychologists in particular."
But before now, in light of the American Catholic bishops' passage of the new sexual abuse charter in June, Yanta said he had no reason to remove any priests with sexual misconduct records, because those incidents occurred many years ago and there were no victims locally.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 07:59:38 PM
In 5 suicides, families blame Father Larson
Robert Larson, convicted of sex crimes he committed as a priest in Kansas, will soon be up for parole. These men's families want to ensure that he stays behind bars.

The Wichita Eagle
BY STAN FINGER
The Wichita Eagle
Five men, five suicides, one thing in common: They were all altar boys for a priest now in prison for committing sex crimes.
Family members say they are convinced their sons killed themselves because they were abused by Robert Larson, who served in the Catholic Diocese of Wichita for 30 years before being removed from the pulpit in 1988 in the wake of molestation allegations.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 07:57:13 PM
BERLIN (Germany)
German Priest Scandal Likely to Widen
Yahoo! News
July 22
By GEIR MOULSON, Associated Press Writer
BERLIN (AP) - Germany will likely see more revelations of sexual abuse of children by Roman Catholic priests, the German church's top official said in comments published Monday as diocesan officials said a priest was forced into retirement for abusing a boy 22 years ago.
Cardinal Karl Lehmann said the church must deal aggressively with sexual abuse and called for common guidelines to prevent and deal with abuse, as well as greater involvement by external experts.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 07:54:55 PM

No U.S. stop for frail Pope
Trip lacks a talk to American Catholics about priest crisis

Albany Times-Union
By FRANK BRUNI, New York Times
ROME -- When Pope John Paul II touches down in Toronto on Tuesday, he will be hardly more than 30 miles from the United States, where Catholics still are reeling from one of the most painful episodes in the American church's history.
The occasion of his trip is the Roman Catholic Church's World Youth Day, the very title of which unintentionally evokes the victims of sexual abuse by priests, which has challenged many American Catholics' faith in their leaders' stewardship.
But at no time during the Pope's nearly weeklong stay in Canada -- or during subsequent days, when he is scheduled to fly over the United States to Guatemala, and then to Mexico -- does he plan to stop in the country to address that problem.

To some American Catholics, that is bitterly disappointing and confusing. But Vatican officials and prominent Catholics close to the Vatican say such a visit never received serious consideration.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:36:47 AM
MENDHAM (N.J.)
Victims describe abuse by a priest they trusted
Bergen-Hackensack Record
By JOHN CHADWICK
Staff Writer
Bill Crane Jr. was a scrawny kid from a financially strapped family.
Paul Steidler's dad was dying of cancer.
Mark Serrano craved attention from his strict father.
Growing up in the Morris County community of Mendham, the three boys and a number of others gravitated to a man who showered them with attention and praise: the Rev. James T. Hanley, the popular pastor of St. Joseph Church. Plump and lively, Hanley acted like a reassuring uncle to the boys as they approached the scary brink of adolescence.
"I was a tiny, scrawny kid, but I felt 6 feet tall and 200 pounds by his kind words," Crane said. "He had a way of making you feel important."
But Hanley's friendship carried a price.
Now in their late 30s and early 40s, the three men and others have over the last four months gone public with stories of sexual abuse at the hands of Hanley.
"He was very successful at getting us when we were sleeping," said Crane, who said he and other boys occasionally slept at the rectory or at a summer home with Hanley. "You would wake up, and you would have no clothes on, and he would have no clothes on."
All told, some 15 people now say they were abused by Hanley. A Phillipsburg lawyer is representing most of them and is seeking a settlement with the Diocese of Paterson.




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:33:39 AM
NAPLES (FL)
Accused priest hosted foreign exchange students
Church prohibition on minor residents escaped student group

Naples Daily News
By ALAN SCHER ZAGIER, aszagier@naplesnews.com
He said his name was Willie, and he came to help a Highlands County woman place two high-school exchange students in her home.
Only later would the woman learn that Willie was the Rev. William Romero, a suspended Catholic priest who in his brief tenure at St. Ann Catholic School in Naples a generation ago molested several young students, according to the now-grown victims.

posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 06:31:06 AM

LONGMEADOW (Mass.)
Priest to fill void at parish
Springfield Union-News
By MICHAEL McAULIFFE
LONGMEADOW — Bishop Thomas L. Dupre, continuing his attempt to bring stability to a parish faced on consecutive days last week with its pastor being accused of sexual abuse and then resigning, spoke at the Masses yesterday at St. Mary's Church.
Dupre, who also addressed parishioners who attended a Saturday afternoon service, said a temporary administrator has been appointed to replace the Rev. Francis P. Lavelle, accused of sexual misconduct in 1972 and 1980. The bishop also said he would be available to speak with parish leaders in the future, should they feel the need.
Dupre said the Rev. Mark Stelzer, son of the late Springfield Police Chief Ernest M. Stelzer, will serve as parish administrator. The bishop said he hoped a new pastor would be selected by Labor Day.
The bishop also detailed the response of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield to the allegations leveled against Lavelle, accused in Hampden Superior Court lawsuits of sexually abusing two men when they were teen-agers. Dupre said that upon learning of the allegations, the diocese reported the information immediately to the Hampden County District Attorney's Office.
Dupre said Lavelle has, in 32 years in the diocese, never before been accused of such conduct.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:23:03 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Laity urge Vatican to open up process of governing church
Boston Herald
by Tom Mashberg
Elated by a weekend ``happening'' that culminated in a 450-strong healing rally with clergy abuse victims late Saturday outside Boston's Cathedral of the Holy Cross, the Bay State-born lay group Voice of the Faithful urged the Vatican yesterday to open up church governance to the rank and file.
The group, which drew 4,200 Catholics to its Saturday convention, said 2,000 of them signed a formal declaration addressed to Pope John Paul II expressing solidarity with the needs of clergy molestation victims and asking for transparency and democracy from an opaque, top-down institution.
``This was nothing less than a spontaneous Catholic happening,'' said James E. Post, a management professor at Boston University and a VOTF founder. ``We are committed to dialogue with all Catholics, including bishops and the hierarchy in Rome. But we will not negotiate our very right to exist, or negotiate our right to be heard.''
As if to drive home its position that both canon law and the Second Vatican Council allow for broad democratic participation in the Roman Catholic Church, the group's declaration even borrowed a resonant phrase from the Declaration of Independence, beginning: ``We the faithful, in order to form a more perfect Church . . . .''


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:19:06 AM
BOSTON (Mass.)
Abuse victims flock to Law
Boston Herald
by Robin Washington
In an extraordinary display of reconciliation among Catholics, a group of priest sex abuse victims and their advocates shed protest signs to join worshipers at Holy Cross Cathedral yesterday, receiving communion from Bernard Cardinal Law.
In response, the prelate asked them - including alleged victim Arthur Austin, whom he instantly recognized - to ``pray for me,'' words the Braintree man said reached directly to his soul.
``It was a very healing moment because it was not the archbishop or the cardinal who spoke to me. It was my brother, Bernie, who responded to me,'' said Austin, who wore a button saying ``reject Cardinal Law'' during the encounter.
``I touched him. I touched him literally and I touched him figuratively. And he was able to receive that. That's the radical grace of God in the world.''
The decision by Austin - who previously called Law ``a criminal, a murderer of children . . . an affront to Jesus Christ'' - and four other victims and advocates to seek communion from the cardinal capped a weekend of bridge-building among disparate groups of Catholics.
Much of that outreach occurred at Saturday's Voice of the Faithful meeting, where thousands of lay Catholics for the first time heard stories of alleged victims firsthand.
Though some VOTF members eschewed protests and more radical actions of victims' groups, their interactions blossomed into a march of 500 from both camps from the Hynes Convention Center to the South End cathedral.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:16:25 AM
LOUISVILLE (KY)
Public scrutiny
Open records best for Louisville diocese, accusers

Louisville Courier-Journal
July 16, 2002
Editorial:
A Jefferson circuit court judge served the public interest with his ruling late last week that lawsuits claiming sexual abuse within the Roman Catholic Church should remain open records.
And the Archdiocese of Louisville is wise not to challenge that decision. Trying to keep the case from view would hurt church efforts to rebuild parishioner and public confidence in its handling of this scandal.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 06:14:37 AM

Catholic Orders Might Keep Abusive Priests
By LAURIE GOODSTEIN
The New York Times
When the leaders of the nation's 125 Roman Catholic religious orders meet next month in Philadelphia, they will confront the issue of what to do with sexually abusive priests who belong to religious orders, like the Jesuits, Franciscans and Benedictines.
One-third of the nation's Catholic priests belong to religious orders, and their fates will be determined not by bishops, but by the major superiors and provincials who lead their orders.
Leaders of the Conference of Major Superiors of Men, which will meet next month, say the orders are unlikely to take the same approach as the nation's bishops.
The bishops agreed last month in most cases to seek to remove from the priesthood priests who had sexually abused a child or an adolescent.
But the leaders of the conference of superiors say they do not expect to take that step. The reason, they say, is that the relationship between a bishop and the priests of his diocese is very different from the relationship between a major superior and the priests, monks and brothers in a religious order.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:11:44 AM
VATICAN
For church, Pope's incapacitation most worrisome
Miami Herald
BY RICHARD BOUDREAUX
Los Angeles Times Service
VATICAN CITY - In plain sight of a global audience, Pope John Paul II has endured an assassin's bullets, a broken hip, four operations, an arthritic knee, the ravages of old age and the debilitating symptoms of Parkinson's disease.
Now, as he prepares for a trip this week to the Americas, the most public of pontiffs is beset by an indignity no predecessor has had to face: increasingly open debate in the Vatican and the Roman Catholic Church over whether he should quit because of ill health.


posted by Bill Mitchell on 7/22/2002 06:07:56 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Law says crisis not focus of meeting
Boston Globe
By Ralph Ranalli, Globe Staff
This week's World Youth Day celebration in Toronto will be a ''time of great spiritual refreshment'' with little if any discussion of the clergy sexual-abuse crisis, Cardinal Bernard F. Law said yesterday.
An estimated 750,000 young Catholics will worship and study together, and Pope John Paul II is expected to attend the celebration, which begins tomorrow.
''I think it will probably be pretty much the way World Youth Day always is,'' Law said in a brief news conference after celebrating Mass at the Cathedral of the Holy Cross with about 300 of the 600 pilgrims who will represent the Archdiocese of Boston in Canada.
''Young people are very resilient. I think that the young people gathered in the cathedral today are very centered in the Lord.''
The sexual abuse scandal ''is being dealt with diocese by diocese,'' Law said. ''I don't believe that that is going to be a principal focus at World Youth Day.''




posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:06:07 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Sex abuse victims prompted to emerge
Church scandal seen as catalyst

Boston Globe
By Kevin Cullen, Globe Staff
Publicity from the clergy sexual abuse scandal has encouraged other sexual abuse victims to step forward, with most making allegations against family members, according to victims' advocates and prosecutors.
Specialists say most of the sexual abuse of children is committed by relatives or caregivers, and prosecutors say the increase in reporting continues to bear out that trend.
At the Boston Area Rape Crisis Center, counselors said they saw an 80 percent increase in calls in January and February, when the initial reports of sexual abuse by priests in the Boston Archdiocese appeared in the Globe, touching off a tidal wave of publicity. Since that time, the increase in calls has slowed only slightly - 336 calls in March compared with 241 last year, 326 calls in April versus 210 last year, and 240 calls in May compared with 206 last year.
Susan Vickers, director of the Victims Rights Law Center, said there is anecdotal evidence that many of the additional reports have been prompted by the clergy abuse scandal.
''I don't know how many of the people coming out are making that direct link, but some are. People often don't know why they are coming forward,'' she said.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 06:02:45 AM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Lay Catholics discuss larger role in church
Portland Press Herald
From staff and news services
BOSTON — At its first national meeting Saturday, a nonclergy reform group born out of the Roman Catholic priest sex abuse scandal called for drastic changes in the way the church is governed.
More than 4,000 Voice of the Faithful members from 35 states and seven foreign countries attended the one-day conference at Boston's Heinz Auditorium. Most signed a petition urging Pope John Paul II to endorse reform policies that U.S. bishops approved in June...
Among the participants were about 25 Mainers from parishes in Belfast, Portland, Auburn, Berwick, Saco, Ellsworth and other communities.
Michael Sweatt, co-founder of the Maine chapter of Voice of the Faithful, said Saturday that he was unaware of any priests from Maine attending. But he said many have been open to the group's efforts at gaining a say in church governance and in opening a dialogue.






posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/22/2002 05:58:25 AM

Sunday, July 21, 2002



The bishop's quandary
Prelate Wilton Gregory is more identified with reform than anyone else at the top of America's Catholic hierarchy. The question is how - and if - this prudent insider will use his power to buck the system.

Boston Globe
By Charles P. Pierce, Globe Staff
This is the way the weather comes. The dust rises. The grass waves. The corn shivers, and the trees shake. The sky lowers and it almost seems suspended on the quivering treetops, and then the weather arrives, all at once: rain and thunder, and lightning striking down in jagged veins until you can smell the ozone burning like a great unbridled fire at the heart of the sky. This is the way the weather comes, swift and sudden, its momentum ceaseless and inexorable, hammering down on the barns and bean fields of southern Illinois, down on the city of Belleville, thrumming off the copper roof of the cathedral from every direction that the wind can bring it down.
Through the stained-glass windows depicting hero priests being scalped by wild Indians, the lightning flashes in deeper colors. The thunder is a distant, choral counterpoint to the singing of a line of priests, walking slowly up the center aisle toward the altar. They've come to honor with a liturgy older priests, some of whom have served for 60 years. The bishop of Belleville will preside over the Mass, and he is in fine voice this evening, singing past the thunder and the steady, percussive rain. As he turns up the center aisle, the bishop winks at a camera crew from Chicago that has come to tape a story about him, because the bishop of Belleville is not just any bishop anymore.
Wilton Gregory stands out in the procession, and not simply because of the accouterments of his office, and not simply because of the touch of kente cloth that adorns both his miter and the stole that drapes his shoulders. Consecrated a bishop when he was only 35 years old, today, at 54, he's a generation younger than several of the priests whom he is honoring. His face is round and animated, and there is still a sort of roll to his walk. Also, he's African-American, and this line of priests is whiter than the Politburo ever was. And he stands out because he is the president of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, which has made him the public face on the greatest crisis the Roman Catholic Church has known since the days in which it was saddled with two popes who hated each other.
Gregory has watched the scandal of clerical sexual abuse run through the church like an underground fire, breaking to the surface here and there until it erupted into a general conflagration over the past year. In the mid-1980s, Gregory saw his mentor, Cardinal Joseph Bernardin of Chicago, develop one of the first policies to deal with the crimes of the clergy and vainly urge it upon the church at large. (He even saw Bernardin, now deceased, himself falsely accused of sexual abuse and survive only because he confronted the charges openly.) In 1993, when Bernardin sent him to Belleville, Gregory walked into a rat's nest of baroque sexual corruption, highlighted by a burglary carried out at one priest's home by a male prostitute from whom the priest regularly received massages in the nude.



posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/21/2002 08:14:26 PM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Law rallies youth, but mum on reform group
Boston.com
By Steve Leblanc, Associated Press,
BOSTON -- Ted Heneberry may not look like a pilgrim, but the lanky 17-year-old high school student clearly sees himself as a defender of his Catholic faith.
Heneberry spent Sunday preparing for the church's World Youth Day in Toronto and rebuffing critics who said Cardinal Bernard Law failed to respond swiftly enough to the church's child sex abuse scandal.
"Most of us just want the fuss to go away. We just want to worship and pray without people from the outside telling us what's wrong," Heneberry said after Mass at the Cathedral of the Holy Cross in Boston. "I don't think I've changed because of this. I don't think the youth of the archdiocese have changed."


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/21/2002 08:09:30 PM

BOSTON (Mass.)
Watch out, Law: The church ladies are now after you
Boston Herald
by Margery Eagan
If his moles reported back truthfully to Bernard Cardinal Law last night, the archbishop of Boston did not sleep well.
What began at the Hynes Convention Center yesterday was the radicalizing of the gray-haired and sensibly shod, of middle-aged and older white, suburban, bred-in-the-bone Catholics from well-heeled parishes in Newton and Wellesley, Winchester and Hingham, Lexington and Medfield.
Catholics whose decades of generosity has kept the weekly collection respectable and archdiocesan accounts sound.
Catholics who grew up pre-liberalizing Vatican II, when missing Latin Mass on Sunday meant damnation, when everyone knelt open-mouthed for Communion - God forbid the faithful should touch the host! When Father So-and-So walked on water, and everybody kissed the bishop's ring, and Holy Mother the Church could never, ever be wrong.
I guess the sensibly shod have a new perspective.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/21/2002 08:02:14 PM
WORCESTER (Mass.)
Handling of Whitcomb case outlined
Worcester Telegram & Gazette
By Kathleen A. Shaw
Telegram & Gazette Staff
WORCESTER-- The Central Association of the Massachusetts Conference of the United Church of Christ, in letters sent to all Congregational Churches in Central Massachusetts, has defended its handling of allegations of impropriety against the Rev. Donald D. Whitcomb of First Congregational Church, Paxton.
The Rev. Paula Elizabeth, chairman of the Central Area Church and Ministry Committee, said the association attempted to resolve the issues quietly, but “the local church chose to bring it to the attention of the media.” News of the church investigation appeared in newspapers, radio and television, she said.
The allegations investigated included one incident of sexual misconduct, which was not corroborated and not acted on; allegations that the minister was present on youth retreats where alcoholic beverages and marijuana were used, and that he provided alcoholic beverages; and that he abrogated professional responsibility and violated certain boundaries expected of a minister, including paying young church vergers on his own and being alone with them.
Members of the Paxton church held a meeting July 11 and vented their dissatisfaction with the process used by the association and discussed leaving the UCC. Church leadership is appealing the association's findings.
The Rev. Nancy Taylor, minister and president of the Massachusetts Conference, said Friday that her only role was to appoint two members to the Response Team that conducted the investigation. The issue was handled by the local association, and she was not privy to what transpired, she said.
The Congregational churches, by design, handle these things at the local level, she said.
“We are not hierarchical,” she said.


posted by Kathy Shaw on 7/21/2002 07:58:16 PM

Clergy Abuse Tracker
More Pre-11/2002 Archives